Pass along a news tip by clicking HERE.
Showing posts with label Anonymous Comments. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Anonymous Comments. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 08, 2008

Ohio Blog Sued By School Principal: Toledo Lawsuit Tackles Anonymous Comments

TOLEDO (TDB) -- SwampBubbles is now caught up in a legal fray that could test whether anonymous commenters on Ohio's blogs can hide their identities. And the lawsuit is likely to give consolation to targets who think they have been defamed and victimized by false statements. The blogosphere can be -- and often is -- a no-holds-barred environment. It is common practice for people to leave anonymous comments. They might suspect there is no trail back to the source. But there is a trail, and it can lead to trouble. Reconstructing the trail might be difficult, -- it can wind through out-of-state Internet service providers and other pit stops on the digital highway -- but it can be traced.

That trail and where it leads seems at the heart of a legal action over anonymous website comments that Leverette Junior High School Principal Steven Riddle considers defamatory. Riddle went to court over postings related to a sexual battery incident involving the arrest of a school employee last November. SwampBubbles is a community blog that covers news, politics and public affairs in NW Ohio. LisaRenee Ward at GlassCityJungle in Toledo has more about the legal fray in Lucas County.

This is the latest flap. Last September, a Republican Wood County Commissioner in Bowling Green was outed as a gay man by an anonymous comment left on Jeff Coryell's Ohio Daily Blog. It was a strategic leak designed to foreclose a bid for Congress in OH-05; there was no court action.

Now, the school principal's lawsuit before Lucas County Common Pleas Judge Gary Cook has LisaRenee musing about anonymous comments. She has concerns. Indeed, the lawsuit probably brings up an issue that needs to be aired: What is fair, and fair game for comment?

At The Daily Bellwether, I kept the comment moderation switch on for months, and limited comments because "anonymous" just made me feel uncomfortable. Then I switched to unmoderated last September and have allowed anybody say anything they wanted -- anonymous or not. In the past few days, I've been growing uneasy about some of the back-and-forth over the OH-02 Democratic primary. There have been some harsh attacks against Steve Black and Vic Wulsin written by "anonymous" people. Now, with lawsuits in the air -- and the courts unlikely to protect anonymous character assassination and assassins who use the Ohiosphere for their attacks -- the time may have come to flip the comment moderation switch on again.

Or, The Bellwether could say that it would vow never to reveal any information ever. That vow clearly would be impossible to keep. A court could order computers seized; it could order Blogger to give up data; it could pry open the browsers. There may be free speech on the Internet, but there may not be any cloak of anonymity for those doing the speaking. The Toledo lawsuit is probably going to make that a lot more clear in the months ahead.

Sunday, December 02, 2007

Anonymous Comment Left On Blog Leads To Arrest: No Secrets On Internet

CINCINNATI (TDB) -- Comments, blogs get comments. And many people who write them do so as "Anonymous" -- assuming that their identities are cloaked, concealed and undiscoverable. But a criminal matter that is unfolding in Wisconsin involving a comment left anonymously on the blog Boots & Sabers reveals there are few secrets in cyber space.

A former teacher's union president in suburban Milwaukee has been arrested after police said they tracked down the source of a Nov. 16 remark that seemed to threaten Columbine-like violence. But the comment -- traced to the teacher's home computer -- actually seems to read like satire, albeit awkward and tasteless satire.

The blog's proprietor, who goes by Owen, cooperated with the cops. He says he agreed to provide the Internet Provider (IP) address to the authorities, but did not suspect there would be an arrest.

[UPDATE: 2:16 pm EST -- Another Wisconsin blogger, Ann Althouse, has looked at the case. She has a link to the criminal statute that the authorities used to make the arrest, which appears to be a catchall criminal measure about misusing a computer. Althouse thinks the police were overzealous. "It would be funny, except that it's not at all funny. The guy doesn't deserve to be arrested."]

An interesting twist is that the teacher who sent the post apparently was pro-union but was writing under cover as a conservative anti-union activist. If the cops are correct, he's been unmasked as a poseur. If the cops are wrong, he was using sarcasms to try and make a point. Here's the comment (misspellings included) that is causing the row:

"Looking at those teacher salary numbers in West Bend made me sick. $60,000 for a part time job were you work maybe 5 hours per day and sit in the teachers lounge and smoke the rest of the time. Thanks God we won on the referendum. But whining here doesn't stop the problem. We've got to get in back of the kids who have had enough of lazy, no good teachers and are fighting back. Kids like Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold, members of the Young Republican club at Columbine. They knew how to deal with the overpaid teacher union thugs. One shot at a time! Too bad the liberals rip them; they were heroes and should be remembered that way."

Those are the words that led to an arrest. Threatening or silly? Meanwhile, the proprietor of Boots and Sabers says the arrest was unwarranted because there was no threat, just an over-the-top remark. He also said the comment had been removed, and that he gave the IP address only to help the cops check it out. "I assumed that they would find him, chew him out a bit for being an idiot, and leave it alone. The fact that the West Bend Police decided to actually arrest him in the absence of any additional evidence of this guy being a threat it out of line."

Bottom line: Anonymous comments can lead to trouble. Be cautious and realize that the Internet does not truly shield your identity. And it looks like the First Amendment's guarantee of free speech has been infringed in Wisconsin.

Tuesday, October 16, 2007

Ohio University Journalism Prof: Dear Editors, Print Anonymous Letters

CINCINNATI (TDB) -- Ohio University journalism professor Bill Reader says it's time for American newspapers to scrap the practice of refusing to print unsigned letters. He says anonymous correspondents often write with clarity, passion and insight but their work is tossed into wastebaskets. He contends it is a myth that unsigned letters are sent out of malice or spite, and said editors cannot really defend as logical the hoary old policy that bans anon from their letters to the editor columns.

Reader, who used to edit letters at the Centre Daily Times in Pennsylvania before turning to academia, sees the prohibition on anonymous correspondence as a barrier to public discourse.

"Having a name doesn't change the responsibility. When I was an editor, I had people give me letters with the names that I definitely couldn't use. But I also got many letters that were brilliant from people who didn't sign their names, which I also couldn't use. There are all kinds of things we use anonymity for to get at the truth: suicide help lines, Alcoholics Anonymous meetings, confession practices in the Catholic Church, closed door government meetings? Why not newspapers?"

Monday, February 19, 2007

'Net Law Expert: Stalking Includes 'Anon' Comments

CINCINNATI (TDB) -- California intellectual property lawyer Eric J. Sinrod recently analyzed the reauthorized U.S. Violence Against Women Act and found language that could damp down some of the feisty nature of Internet exchanges. Sinrod said he located wording that makes it a crime punishable by jail to "annoy" someone. He worried that legal tools could smoke out the people behind pointed anonymous commentary, thus harming free speech. Sinrod's Findlaw.com column is HERE.

These four-paragraphs register the depth of his worry:

"A small but important provision buried deep in the Violence Against Women and Department of Justice Reauthorization Act of 2005, H.R. 3402, titled "Preventing Cyberstalking" and numbered as Section 113, which was just signed into law, now brings the reach of Section 223(a)(1)(C), quoted above, home to the Internet.

"Specifically, Section 113(a)(3) provides that Section 223(a)(1)(C) applies to "any device or software that can be used to originate telecommunications or other types of communications that are transmitted, in whole or in part, by the Internet." Hello!

"What does this mean? The Communications Act provides for fines and imprisonment of up to two years for violations. Thus, taken to a logical extreme conclusion, it is possible that a person who makes a Web posting or who sends an email that is intended simply to "annoy" someone else while not disclosing his or her true identity, could be subject to fines and jail time.

"So much for freedom of speech - so much for appropriate Internet anonymity. There is no requirement of harm to trigger the impact of this new law, and the annoyance standard raises a number of concerns."

There is more detail about Sinrod HERE.