COLUMBUS (TDB) -- A state lawyer at the Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles says the agency cannot comply with a federal subpoena that seeks access to the driver's license photos of 1,419 Ohioans. The lawyer, Joshua Engel, contends a privacy law blocks release of the photographs. The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission subpoenaed the photos on Feb. 15 for an investigation into allegations of hiring discrimination by two Toledo companies, Modern Builders' Supply Inc. and Polaris Technologies. The EEOC says "examination of the job applicants' license photographs will allow the Commission to statistically analyze the job applicant flow by race and sex. The result of such analysis will assist EEOC in completing its investigation and make its determination on the race and sex hiring allegations."
Earlier this week, U.S. Magistrate Mark R. Abel scheduled a May 30 show cause hearing in Columbus federal court. The judge gave the state until May 16 to explain why it has not complied with the subpoena. The case is EEOC v. Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles, 2:08-mc-00015.
EEOC lawyers contend Ohio is hampering a federal investigation. But Engel, chief legal counsel for the Ohio Department of Public Safety, parent of the BMV, said in a letter to the EEOC that, "We are not permitted to prove the records in response to this Subpoena. The Subpoena requests photographs of approximately 1.500 Ohio drivers. However, Ohio law prohibits the release of such records."
EEOC lawyers say that amounts to legal bunkum:
"Respondent grounds its refusal to comply with the subpoena on an Ohio law which prohibits release of digitized license photographs, except for criminal justice purposes or to a court . . . State laws which frustrate federal investigations under federal laws such as Title VII, however, are preempted by federal law under the Constitution's Supremacy Clause. The federal courts have rejected state privacy and other laws as defenses to EEOC Title VII subpoena enforcement actions because Title VII is the supreme law of the land, preempting those state laws . . . The Commission is proceeding with an investigation which is within its Congressionally-mandated authority."
Showing posts with label Privacy Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Privacy Law. Show all posts
Thursday, May 01, 2008
Thursday, March 15, 2007
Kucinich Wants Law Limiting Military Recruiters In Schools
CINCINNATI (TDB) -- Cleveland Rep. Dennis Kucinich, a Democrat running for president on an anti-war platform, signed up last week to cosponsor a measure designed to reduce access military recruiters now have to high school students. The bill, H.R. 1346, amends the No Child Left Behind Act and blocks schools from releasing student information to military officials without parental parental consent.
Chief sponsor Rep. Mike Honda, a California Democrat whose district includes the Silicon Valley, said his measure ensures student information remains private if parents want it that way. Under current law, parents have to opt-out of the recruiting notification program, and many times they fail to fill out the paperwork or don't see it. Honda said he has "greatest respect" for the military but thinks privacy rights trump the Pentagon's recruitment efforts.
The National Education Association, the nation's largest teachers union, and National PTA are supporting the privacy plan. Kucinich is one of 37 congressional cosponsors. Honda's remarks when he filed the bill last week follow:
"Mr. HONDA. Madam Speaker, I rise today to announce the introduction of my bill, the Student Privacy Protection Act.
"The Student Privacy Protection Act is legislation that will restore the privacy rights of children and families that were taken away by a little-known provision of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, the so-called No Child Left Behind Act.
"Under No Child Left Behind, high schools are required to turn over lists of student contact information to the Department of Defense, which adds this information to an extensive database of children. The Department of Defense claims to need the names, addresses, and phone numbers of high school students for recruiting purposes, because it enables recruiters to contact children directly in their homes and at school, which is often done without the knowledge or consent of their parents.
"As a former high school teacher and principal, I am concerned that the fundamental right of privacy has been taken away from both parents and children. U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis defined privacy as 'the right to be left alone.' Families are not being left alone, and their personal, private information is being divulged without their knowledge. Any database of personal information is subject to abuse. A government that was established for the pursuit of life, liberty, and happiness has no business collecting extensive personal data about Americans.
"I have the greatest respect for Americans who choose to enter the military, as well as for those in the Armed Forces who engage in the recruiting process. Those efforts, however, should respect the privacy rights of children and their families.'
No Child Left Behind requires schools to give military recruiters the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of students, unless their parents 'opt-out' of the list. Schools are only required to provide one notice of the military recruiting list, so it can be easily overlooked by parents, or perhaps never received. Moreover, language and cultural barriers can prevent understanding of the opt-out process, especially in immigrant communities that are subject to aggressive military recruiting. If parents do not respond, and do not explicitly object to having their child's personal information released to recruiters, it is assumed that they have no objections. Under current law, they must 'opt-out' in order to protect their rights.
The privacy rights of all Americans should be respected. One should not have to ask for these rights. Today, I am reintroducing the Student Privacy Protection Act, which I introduced in the 109th Congress. This legislation will restore the privacy rights of parents and children. The Student Privacy Protection Act will change the military recruitment provision of No Child Left Behind from an 'opt-out'' system to 'opt-in.' Under my bill, families may still choose to 'opt-in' to the recruiting database, but privacy will be respected by default. I urge my colleagues to join me in supporting the rights of students and the rights of families, by supporting the Student Privacy Protection Act."
Chief sponsor Rep. Mike Honda, a California Democrat whose district includes the Silicon Valley, said his measure ensures student information remains private if parents want it that way. Under current law, parents have to opt-out of the recruiting notification program, and many times they fail to fill out the paperwork or don't see it. Honda said he has "greatest respect" for the military but thinks privacy rights trump the Pentagon's recruitment efforts.
The National Education Association, the nation's largest teachers union, and National PTA are supporting the privacy plan. Kucinich is one of 37 congressional cosponsors. Honda's remarks when he filed the bill last week follow:
"Mr. HONDA. Madam Speaker, I rise today to announce the introduction of my bill, the Student Privacy Protection Act.
"The Student Privacy Protection Act is legislation that will restore the privacy rights of children and families that were taken away by a little-known provision of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, the so-called No Child Left Behind Act.
"Under No Child Left Behind, high schools are required to turn over lists of student contact information to the Department of Defense, which adds this information to an extensive database of children. The Department of Defense claims to need the names, addresses, and phone numbers of high school students for recruiting purposes, because it enables recruiters to contact children directly in their homes and at school, which is often done without the knowledge or consent of their parents.
"As a former high school teacher and principal, I am concerned that the fundamental right of privacy has been taken away from both parents and children. U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis defined privacy as 'the right to be left alone.' Families are not being left alone, and their personal, private information is being divulged without their knowledge. Any database of personal information is subject to abuse. A government that was established for the pursuit of life, liberty, and happiness has no business collecting extensive personal data about Americans.
"I have the greatest respect for Americans who choose to enter the military, as well as for those in the Armed Forces who engage in the recruiting process. Those efforts, however, should respect the privacy rights of children and their families.'
No Child Left Behind requires schools to give military recruiters the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of students, unless their parents 'opt-out' of the list. Schools are only required to provide one notice of the military recruiting list, so it can be easily overlooked by parents, or perhaps never received. Moreover, language and cultural barriers can prevent understanding of the opt-out process, especially in immigrant communities that are subject to aggressive military recruiting. If parents do not respond, and do not explicitly object to having their child's personal information released to recruiters, it is assumed that they have no objections. Under current law, they must 'opt-out' in order to protect their rights.
The privacy rights of all Americans should be respected. One should not have to ask for these rights. Today, I am reintroducing the Student Privacy Protection Act, which I introduced in the 109th Congress. This legislation will restore the privacy rights of parents and children. The Student Privacy Protection Act will change the military recruitment provision of No Child Left Behind from an 'opt-out'' system to 'opt-in.' Under my bill, families may still choose to 'opt-in' to the recruiting database, but privacy will be respected by default. I urge my colleagues to join me in supporting the rights of students and the rights of families, by supporting the Student Privacy Protection Act."
Wednesday, January 03, 2007
Hartmann, County Win Internet Identity-Theft Case
CINCINNATI (TDB) -- The U.S. Constitution's "right to privacy" does not cover an Ohio woman who claimed she became the victim of identity-theft because Hamilton County Clerk of Courts Greg Hartmann's office routinely posted public records on the Internet in an effort to broaden access. A federal judge dismissed Cynthia Lambert's lawsuit last week and found that the government's interest in disseminating information can trump an individual's expectation of keeping it private.
The case appears to be the first of its kind decided in a federal court, and at this point is a victory for those who favor few restrictions on Internet access to public records and government documents. However, there is likely to be an appeal.
Hartmann was the Republican candidate for Ohio Secretary of State last year, and he had posted millions of records on his office Web site -- everything from divorces to traffic tickets and citations for unpaid taxes. The records are open to public inspection by law in Ohio. Hartmann's policy extended them to the Internet, which extended access to the entire world. At one time, he had about 6 million records posted on the Web. Access has been curtailed over the past year because of ID-theft abuses. Lambert was the first victim to sue the county for financial damages.
In September 2003, Lambert received a speeding ticket in Blue Ash, Ohio, a Cincinnati suburb, and the officer filled out the Ohio Uniform Traffic Ticket form, which included her name, signature, address, birth date, driver's license and Social Security numbers. The ticket was published on the county Web site.
About a year later, Lambert got calls from a Sam's Club store that somebody using her identity had bought $8,000 worth of electronics, and a Home Depot, where $12,000 was charged to a credit card in her name. Lambert learned that an ID thief used an Ohio driver's license to open the accounts. All identifying factors used by the crook matched Lambert except one -- the license number was a single digit different than her own. When Lambert checked the county Web site, she found the speeding ticket posted there was off by the same digit due to an error by the citing officer in Blue Ash.
In 2004 she filed suit in U.S. District Court claiming economic damages, harm to her reputation and credit rating and violation of her privacy rights. (Southern District of Ohio, 1:04-cv-837.)
U.S. District Judge Michael H. Watson said he was sympathetic to Lambert, but added the issues she raised were not proper for a federal lawsuit. ''The court determines that plaintiff's alleged privacy interest in her name, signature, home address, birth date, driver's license number and Social Security number do not implicate either a fundamental right or one implicit in the concept of ordered liberty. Plaintiff has only identified a risk of financial harm,'' Watson wrote.
Watson said Lambert could refile her lawsuit in the state court system to pursue any claims under Ohio law, including a right to be free from identity theft. ''The court finds that the issues presented are more appropriate for resolution by the state court system and therefore the court declines to exercise its supplemental jurisdiction,'' he said.
The case appears to be the first of its kind decided in a federal court, and at this point is a victory for those who favor few restrictions on Internet access to public records and government documents. However, there is likely to be an appeal.
Hartmann was the Republican candidate for Ohio Secretary of State last year, and he had posted millions of records on his office Web site -- everything from divorces to traffic tickets and citations for unpaid taxes. The records are open to public inspection by law in Ohio. Hartmann's policy extended them to the Internet, which extended access to the entire world. At one time, he had about 6 million records posted on the Web. Access has been curtailed over the past year because of ID-theft abuses. Lambert was the first victim to sue the county for financial damages.
In September 2003, Lambert received a speeding ticket in Blue Ash, Ohio, a Cincinnati suburb, and the officer filled out the Ohio Uniform Traffic Ticket form, which included her name, signature, address, birth date, driver's license and Social Security numbers. The ticket was published on the county Web site.
About a year later, Lambert got calls from a Sam's Club store that somebody using her identity had bought $8,000 worth of electronics, and a Home Depot, where $12,000 was charged to a credit card in her name. Lambert learned that an ID thief used an Ohio driver's license to open the accounts. All identifying factors used by the crook matched Lambert except one -- the license number was a single digit different than her own. When Lambert checked the county Web site, she found the speeding ticket posted there was off by the same digit due to an error by the citing officer in Blue Ash.
In 2004 she filed suit in U.S. District Court claiming economic damages, harm to her reputation and credit rating and violation of her privacy rights. (Southern District of Ohio, 1:04-cv-837.)
U.S. District Judge Michael H. Watson said he was sympathetic to Lambert, but added the issues she raised were not proper for a federal lawsuit. ''The court determines that plaintiff's alleged privacy interest in her name, signature, home address, birth date, driver's license number and Social Security number do not implicate either a fundamental right or one implicit in the concept of ordered liberty. Plaintiff has only identified a risk of financial harm,'' Watson wrote.
Watson said Lambert could refile her lawsuit in the state court system to pursue any claims under Ohio law, including a right to be free from identity theft. ''The court finds that the issues presented are more appropriate for resolution by the state court system and therefore the court declines to exercise its supplemental jurisdiction,'' he said.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)