CINCINNATI (TDB) -- For nearly four years now, Jean Dubail has been responsible for moving newspaper content from The Plain Dealer to its digital companion, Cleveland.com. Today, the newsroom learned the veteran editor -- he's been a fixture at Ohio's largest daily for going on two decades -- is leaving newsprint behind. He's resigned to enlist with Patch.com, an AOL venture that is moving to publish digital news in communities like inner city neighborhoods and suburbs. Patch is hiring 500 journalists and expanding into 500 communities in 20 states by the end of this year. Ohio looks to be on the radar, and the Cincinnati Enquirer, along with the state's other newspapers, could find itself facing a challenger. Dubail is supposed to be a regional editor, although that might not be the exact title. Patch is aiming to become a direct competitor of the dinosaur media's efforts to grab online customers as print fades from its 20th Century heyday. With people like Dubail aboard the fade may come much quicker. AOL has been touting Patch and a recent press release about its entry into 100 communities is available here. Patch has been actively recruiting veteran reporters and editors; newspapers, TV stations, wire services and traditional media outlets have been downsizing.
Dubail, a St. Louis native, was the The Plain Dealer's top local news editor between 1999 and 2006. On the metro desk, he supervised nearly 90 journalists and was sharp, extremely competent and a popular figure in the newsroom. He was also able to see ahead into the digital era, an insight and ability that other newspaper execs lacked. Dubail advocated for The Plain Dealer to enter the cyber era, and was the founding father of OPEN, the paper's Ohio political blog. He also was an editorial writer and local news reporter. As for Patch, I found this on the website:
"The Patch.org Foundation was formed in March, 2010 to improve the quality of life in underserved communities across the globe through access to trusted local news and information.
"What we do
The Patch.org Foundation plans to partner with community foundations and other organizations to fund the operation of Patch news and information sites in communities that need them most: inner-city neighborhoods and underserved towns around the world.
"What we look for
We will look for communities of 15-100k population that are drastically underserved by media and would benefit by having access to local news and information about government, schools and business. These could be inner-city neighborhoods or distinct towns. For more information email foundation@patch.com."
Showing posts with label Cleveland Plain Dealer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cleveland Plain Dealer. Show all posts
Tuesday, September 21, 2010
Sunday, August 03, 2008
Ohio Sen. Sherrod Brown's Spouse Writes Glowingly About Michelle Obama: Did Democratic Politics Trump Journalism Ethics?
CLEVELAND (TDB) -- Cleveland newspaper columnist Connie Schultz writes glowingly about Michelle Obama, another Democratic U.S. senator's wife whom she landed for a major interview. Schultz seems to be dabbling in politics, a subject that former Cleveland Plain Dealer editor Doug Clifton -- who retired last year -- intended to keep out of her column. He was concerned about the potential for conflict, that conservative and Republican readers might see the paper as taking sides. In December 2006, Clifton told Cleveland Scene: "It's a very tough line to walk between being a journalist and being politicized. She'll have to be above reproach in matters concerning her husband. For my money, it would be best that she never even mentions that she had a husband. If I were looking for an ideal situation, I'd want a reader a year from now to be shocked an amazed that she was married to a U.S. Senator."
Michelle's husband is the Democratic presidential candidate; Cleveland newspaper columnist Connie's husband is Ohio's Democratic U.S. Senator. Connie's husband is doing all he can to help Michelle's husband move into the White House. Thus, the column by Connie could raise suspicion that she is doing the same, along with chatter that Ohio's largest newspaper also has shed any semblance of sitting on the sidelines during this presidential campaign season. Connie writes that the chief reason she wanted to interview Michelle -- and write a column -- is because "Michelle Obama is, indeed, auditioning for first lady and a lot of voters don't know much about her beyond media controversies."
So she sets about painting Michelle as a regular mom who shops at Target, and adds "Like most mothers, Michelle Obama relishes the daily mess of life as a parent. She also struggles with the maternal guilt so typical of working mothers." Connie explains she wanted to track down Michelle because they shared something in common -- husbands in the Senate:
"There's another reason I wanted to talk to Michelle Obama and it's personal. Like her, I am the wife of a U.S. senator. In many ways, she and I head dramatically different lives, but both of us are mothers and career women who know what it feels like to put our own lives on hold to support politically ambitious husbands. We've lost count of the times we've been introduced as 'the lovely wife' and we know there are always some campaign veterans who consider women like us either a prop or a problems in their husbands' races. So we had plenty to talk about."
Connie said she's waiting to hear from Cindy McCain, the wife of Arizona U.S. Senator John McCain. He's the Republican presidential candidate, the guy Sherrod Brown wants to Obama to defeat.
Michelle's husband is the Democratic presidential candidate; Cleveland newspaper columnist Connie's husband is Ohio's Democratic U.S. Senator. Connie's husband is doing all he can to help Michelle's husband move into the White House. Thus, the column by Connie could raise suspicion that she is doing the same, along with chatter that Ohio's largest newspaper also has shed any semblance of sitting on the sidelines during this presidential campaign season. Connie writes that the chief reason she wanted to interview Michelle -- and write a column -- is because "Michelle Obama is, indeed, auditioning for first lady and a lot of voters don't know much about her beyond media controversies."
So she sets about painting Michelle as a regular mom who shops at Target, and adds "Like most mothers, Michelle Obama relishes the daily mess of life as a parent. She also struggles with the maternal guilt so typical of working mothers." Connie explains she wanted to track down Michelle because they shared something in common -- husbands in the Senate:
"There's another reason I wanted to talk to Michelle Obama and it's personal. Like her, I am the wife of a U.S. senator. In many ways, she and I head dramatically different lives, but both of us are mothers and career women who know what it feels like to put our own lives on hold to support politically ambitious husbands. We've lost count of the times we've been introduced as 'the lovely wife' and we know there are always some campaign veterans who consider women like us either a prop or a problems in their husbands' races. So we had plenty to talk about."
Connie said she's waiting to hear from Cindy McCain, the wife of Arizona U.S. Senator John McCain. He's the Republican presidential candidate, the guy Sherrod Brown wants to Obama to defeat.
Tuesday, May 13, 2008
Plain Dealer Reports: Ohio AG Marc Dann To Resign, Telling Staff Today
UPDATE -- The Akron Beacon Journal says Dann's resignation won't be today. The news reports are now being described as "premature."
CLEVELAND (TDB) -- The Plain Dealer says he's going to step down this afternoon. A source in Columbus who serves in the Ohio House and is close to Dann has confirmed the story for The Daily Bellwether. And the Columbus Dispatch is reporting that the attorney general has been meeting in his office with Lt. Gov. Lee Fisher and working out terms for a resignation and departure from state government. Fisher -- who is No.2 to Gov. Ted Strickland -- served as attorney general from 1991 through 1995 and has knowledge of the inner workings of the office that Dann has held since early January 2007.
CLEVELAND (TDB) -- The Plain Dealer says he's going to step down this afternoon. A source in Columbus who serves in the Ohio House and is close to Dann has confirmed the story for The Daily Bellwether. And the Columbus Dispatch is reporting that the attorney general has been meeting in his office with Lt. Gov. Lee Fisher and working out terms for a resignation and departure from state government. Fisher -- who is No.2 to Gov. Ted Strickland -- served as attorney general from 1991 through 1995 and has knowledge of the inner workings of the office that Dann has held since early January 2007.
Friday, May 02, 2008
Full Text Of Marc Dann's Testimony: 176 Pages About Ohio Sex Harassment Scandal
The first 157 pages are here (pdf). Another 19 pages are here. The transcript comes courtesy of The Plain Dealer, which has also posted the complete text of the sexual harassment investigation on the newspaper's website.
Saturday, March 22, 2008
Ohio's Biggest Newspapers To Start Sharing Content: Toledo Blade Stories Coming To Cincinnati Enquirer?
AKRON (TDB) -- Editors at the state's seven largest newspapers have been pushing The Associated Press for speedier and more comprehensive statewide coverage. The editors also pressed the wire service for a rate schedule that doesn't sock them with excessive fees. And they've been perplexed -- Why is it that AP distributes Ohio news (often culled from an Ohio newspaper) to Google or Yahoo quicker than we can get it to our readers? The editors have seen how blogs grab their news from Google and Yahoo, redistributing it for free. Now, the state's seven biggest papers have agreed to create their own content-sharing program, which is scheduled for launch on Monday. Stories from Cleveland's Plain Dealer and Toledo's Blade should soon turn up in the Cincinnati Enquirer. Editor & Publisher, a journalism trade publication and Web site, broke the news about the content-sharing arrangement.
My own supposition is that this is more about the Web and getting news material online rather than in print. Newsholes are shrunken -- with fewer pages and smaller page sizes -- and space for large numbers of stories is not available in the ad-thin print newspapers of today. Meanwhile, staffs are smaller because of downsizing, buyouts and hiring freezes. So there are fewer reporters around Ohio producing news stories. The editors are trying to adjust by picking up content from other newsroom staffs to cover what they cannot get to. The editors also want readers to recognize that the work was produced by a journalist on the payroll of a newspaper. This is a sea change, because it signals an effort, at the highest levels, to downplay and partially bury journalism-rooted jealousies and rivalries in existence for generations, the ethos of the scoop. The Plain Dealer staff has always taken great joy in kicking the ass of the Columbus Dispatch on a big story, and vice versa. But soon Dispatch news will be appearing under The Plain Dealer nameplate. Unthinkable just a few years ago.
Akron Beacon Journal editor Bruce Winges noted in an internal staff memo that Cleveland and Canton content initially will not show up in Akron. The three newspapers are competitors in the NEO market. But stories from other corners of the state will be fully credited "with byline and dateline. The other papers will do the same with our content."
Said Winges:
"I am sure there will be bumps along the way as we get this exchange going. We will get through them. This idea of content sharing is not about cutting back what we do. It is about sharing our content with the other large Ohio newspapers and getting their content in return. The goal is to have stories that benefit the readers of all of our newspapers. A secondary benefit is that readers will know how much is produced by our newsrooms."
My own supposition is that this is more about the Web and getting news material online rather than in print. Newsholes are shrunken -- with fewer pages and smaller page sizes -- and space for large numbers of stories is not available in the ad-thin print newspapers of today. Meanwhile, staffs are smaller because of downsizing, buyouts and hiring freezes. So there are fewer reporters around Ohio producing news stories. The editors are trying to adjust by picking up content from other newsroom staffs to cover what they cannot get to. The editors also want readers to recognize that the work was produced by a journalist on the payroll of a newspaper. This is a sea change, because it signals an effort, at the highest levels, to downplay and partially bury journalism-rooted jealousies and rivalries in existence for generations, the ethos of the scoop. The Plain Dealer staff has always taken great joy in kicking the ass of the Columbus Dispatch on a big story, and vice versa. But soon Dispatch news will be appearing under The Plain Dealer nameplate. Unthinkable just a few years ago.
Akron Beacon Journal editor Bruce Winges noted in an internal staff memo that Cleveland and Canton content initially will not show up in Akron. The three newspapers are competitors in the NEO market. But stories from other corners of the state will be fully credited "with byline and dateline. The other papers will do the same with our content."
Said Winges:
"I am sure there will be bumps along the way as we get this exchange going. We will get through them. This idea of content sharing is not about cutting back what we do. It is about sharing our content with the other large Ohio newspapers and getting their content in return. The goal is to have stories that benefit the readers of all of our newspapers. A secondary benefit is that readers will know how much is produced by our newsrooms."
Friday, March 07, 2008
The Top Editor Of Ohio's Largest Newspaper: More Shoes Than Imelda Marcos?
CLEVELAND (TDB) -- Susan Goldberg has been running The Plain Dealer for the past seven months. A profile in this month's Cleveland Magazine gives her a favorable review. The city mag's March issue also notes she's a clothes horse who shows up for work in "high heels and classically elegant outfits, including St. John's knits." It reports Goldberg once quipped, "I just so happen to have a collection of high heels Imelda Marcos would envy."
She is the first female to run the newsroom at the state's largest daily. Women, she told the magazine, see news differently than men. And she suspects that might lead to superior journalism:
"Female journalists are as aggressive, if not more so, than the men when it comes to nailing a story or a bad guy. [But] women as a group, have a broader, less traditional definition of what news is than many men do, and I think we have life experiences that can help us connect better with our readers. I make no apology for seeking out, and displaying well, stories that blatantly appeal to women."
Erick Trickey wrote the Cleveland Magazine piece about Goldberg, who comes off as neither Imelda nor a Devil Wears Prada wannabe. Some of the kinds of stories that Goldberg puts on the front page: Hormone replacement therapy, maternity leave laws, the Iron Chef. Some that critics say get short shrift: Reports from the Iraq War.
She is the first female to run the newsroom at the state's largest daily. Women, she told the magazine, see news differently than men. And she suspects that might lead to superior journalism:
"Female journalists are as aggressive, if not more so, than the men when it comes to nailing a story or a bad guy. [But] women as a group, have a broader, less traditional definition of what news is than many men do, and I think we have life experiences that can help us connect better with our readers. I make no apology for seeking out, and displaying well, stories that blatantly appeal to women."
Erick Trickey wrote the Cleveland Magazine piece about Goldberg, who comes off as neither Imelda nor a Devil Wears Prada wannabe. Some of the kinds of stories that Goldberg puts on the front page: Hormone replacement therapy, maternity leave laws, the Iron Chef. Some that critics say get short shrift: Reports from the Iraq War.
Tuesday, February 05, 2008
Ohio Newspaper Web Traffic: Cincinnati Enquirer Beats Cleveland Plain Dealer
CINCINNATI (TDB) -- Fresh stats are out ranking the nation's newspapers by the average number of visitors attracted monthly to their online editions. In Ohio, the Cincinnati Enquirer -- the state's third-largest print publication -- owns the busiest Web portal with an average 1.034 million visits per month. If you figure that the print paper sells about 200,000 copies per day, that's about five days circulation. In Cleveland, monthly 'net traffic equals about three days circulation -- which indicates the shift to online still has a long way to grow. The complete list of the Top 100 newspaper Web sites and their monthly stats March through August is available by clicking here.
In Ohio, there are no numbers for the Dayton Daily News, which didn't show up in the Top 100. Here are the standings when monthly numbers were averaged by Nielsen/NetRatings:
Cincinnati Enquirer -- 1. Ohio; 30. US; 1.034 million unique visitors per month.
Cleveland Plain Dealer -- 2. Ohio; 32. US; 989,000 per month.
Columbus Dispatch -- 3. Ohio; 65. US; 547,000 per month.
Akron Beacon Journal -- 4. Ohio; 75. US; 415,00 per month.
Toledo Blade -- 5. Ohio; 90. US; 315,000 per month.
The biggest mystery: Why does the Dispatch fare so poorly? With Ohio State and the state government in its front yard, there should be legions of 'net savvy readers visiting online. H/T Brewed Fresh Daily, the uber-blog of George Nemeth.
In Ohio, there are no numbers for the Dayton Daily News, which didn't show up in the Top 100. Here are the standings when monthly numbers were averaged by Nielsen/NetRatings:
Cincinnati Enquirer -- 1. Ohio; 30. US; 1.034 million unique visitors per month.
Cleveland Plain Dealer -- 2. Ohio; 32. US; 989,000 per month.
Columbus Dispatch -- 3. Ohio; 65. US; 547,000 per month.
Akron Beacon Journal -- 4. Ohio; 75. US; 415,00 per month.
Toledo Blade -- 5. Ohio; 90. US; 315,000 per month.
The biggest mystery: Why does the Dispatch fare so poorly? With Ohio State and the state government in its front yard, there should be legions of 'net savvy readers visiting online. H/T Brewed Fresh Daily, the uber-blog of George Nemeth.
Monday, January 21, 2008
Cleveland Plain Dealer Censors The N-Word: Hooray For Editors!!!
CLEVELAND (TDB) -- The newspaper management's account of the internal wrangling before it reached the decision is reported by reader rep Ted Diadiun. His column drew a retort from Gawker, which questioned the reasoning:
"If the Ohio newspaper wants to take political correctness to an extreme, fine. For consistency's sake, the PC police might want to do a purge of the Plain Dealer's archives, where there are several instances of the n-word making it through intact onto the the page."
My own history at The Plain Dealer: I used the the n-word once in print (that I recall), as a quote in a 1988 piece about Jesse Jackson's run in the Democratic presidential primary. A white senior citizen in Ironton said he planned to vote for Jackson, despite the fact the candidate was a n-----. His words surprised me and it was a quote that I never expected to see reach print. The geezer's point seemed to be that he thought Jackson was right on a lot of the issues though he didn't like the candidate's skin color. There was quite a flap after the quote appeared. And rightly so.
"If the Ohio newspaper wants to take political correctness to an extreme, fine. For consistency's sake, the PC police might want to do a purge of the Plain Dealer's archives, where there are several instances of the n-word making it through intact onto the the page."
My own history at The Plain Dealer: I used the the n-word once in print (that I recall), as a quote in a 1988 piece about Jesse Jackson's run in the Democratic presidential primary. A white senior citizen in Ironton said he planned to vote for Jackson, despite the fact the candidate was a n-----. His words surprised me and it was a quote that I never expected to see reach print. The geezer's point seemed to be that he thought Jackson was right on a lot of the issues though he didn't like the candidate's skin color. There was quite a flap after the quote appeared. And rightly so.
Thursday, December 13, 2007
Ohio Again Beckons Hollywood: State Re-Establishes Its Film Office
COLUMBUS (TDB) -- The official press release is here. But the film community is wondering what Christina Grozik likes to watch with her popcorn. She's been picked to lure movie makers back into Ohio. Turns out her favorite flick is 1994's The Shawshank Redemption. It's a prison film based on a Stephen King story that was shot around Mansfield and the old state pen there. Some give Shawshank two thumbs up as one of the best American movies ever. Grozik is a huge fan and has put it on a list of the all time greats.
She used to be a wheel at Cleveland's Film Commission and explained to The Plain Dealer's pdq a couple years ago what made Shawshank her favorite. The Daily Bellwether dug out her review:
"Best scene: Andy Dufresne (Tim Robbins) locks himself in the warden's office and plays a record on the loud speaker for the whole prison facility to hear. The way the faces of the prisoners light up when they hear the intensely soothing sounds of the two Italian women singing . . . it can't be expressed in words.
"Why this picture belongs in pdq's ultimate collection: I think the tag line of the film says it best: 'Fear can hold you prisoner. Hope can set you free.' It's an intelligent film with incredible cinematography and amazing performances, not to mention the fact the film was shot in Ohio. I believe the movie is magical in many ways. It sends a powerful message that beauty is contained within us, and no matter what difficulties you encounter, you should never let anyone take that beauty away from you."
She used to be a wheel at Cleveland's Film Commission and explained to The Plain Dealer's pdq a couple years ago what made Shawshank her favorite. The Daily Bellwether dug out her review:
"Best scene: Andy Dufresne (Tim Robbins) locks himself in the warden's office and plays a record on the loud speaker for the whole prison facility to hear. The way the faces of the prisoners light up when they hear the intensely soothing sounds of the two Italian women singing . . . it can't be expressed in words.
"Why this picture belongs in pdq's ultimate collection: I think the tag line of the film says it best: 'Fear can hold you prisoner. Hope can set you free.' It's an intelligent film with incredible cinematography and amazing performances, not to mention the fact the film was shot in Ohio. I believe the movie is magical in many ways. It sends a powerful message that beauty is contained within us, and no matter what difficulties you encounter, you should never let anyone take that beauty away from you."
Tuesday, October 30, 2007
Splitsville In Cleveland: A Marriage Of MSM And Blogs Ends In Bitter Divorce
CINCINNATI (TDB) -- The news that an independent blogger was served with divorce papers from his paid gig with The Plain Dealer because of partisan political activities should be as about as surprising as Liz Taylor ditching a beau. Who really thought the match was made in heaven? The blogs are sluttily bodacious like Mae West, while the newspapers are a stockholders' business.
Remember Fitzgerald, writing in The Last Tycoon:
"'Why, you can hire anyone,' exclaimed his visitor in surprise.
'Oh, we hire them, but when they get out here, they're not good writers -- so we have to work with the material we have.'
'Such as what?'
'Anybody that'll accept the system and stay decently sober.'"
But we have this and this and this and this and this. And this, too, plus this and this. Didn't anybody sense that blogs and newspapers made strange bedfellows?
[UPDATE: 9:58 p.m. -- Lisa Renee Ward at Glass City Jungle weighs in by calling The Plain Dealer asshats, and Jerid at Buckeye State Blog openly mocks Wide Open for failing to remove content by a blogger it has removed. Jeff Coryell says The Plain Dealer's editor sent out an e-mail that inaccurately contends the newspaper did not bow to political pressure over the disagreement that lead to his parting company with Susan Goldberg's publication. As Ohio Goes points out that other Plain Dealer bloggers have contributed to political campaigns, and notes that bloggers often are politically active.]
On a blog, conversation does not range from Gertrude Stein, to tea, George III and 18th Century French portraitists. It's about breaking dishes in the kitchen. Newspapers are the gentlemanly butlers serving pot roast in the dining room. The blogs have a freshness and vitality; the newspapers are stony, like a statue.
Remember Fitzgerald, writing in The Last Tycoon:
"'Why, you can hire anyone,' exclaimed his visitor in surprise.
'Oh, we hire them, but when they get out here, they're not good writers -- so we have to work with the material we have.'
'Such as what?'
'Anybody that'll accept the system and stay decently sober.'"
But we have this and this and this and this and this. And this, too, plus this and this. Didn't anybody sense that blogs and newspapers made strange bedfellows?
[UPDATE: 9:58 p.m. -- Lisa Renee Ward at Glass City Jungle weighs in by calling The Plain Dealer asshats, and Jerid at Buckeye State Blog openly mocks Wide Open for failing to remove content by a blogger it has removed. Jeff Coryell says The Plain Dealer's editor sent out an e-mail that inaccurately contends the newspaper did not bow to political pressure over the disagreement that lead to his parting company with Susan Goldberg's publication. As Ohio Goes points out that other Plain Dealer bloggers have contributed to political campaigns, and notes that bloggers often are politically active.]
On a blog, conversation does not range from Gertrude Stein, to tea, George III and 18th Century French portraitists. It's about breaking dishes in the kitchen. Newspapers are the gentlemanly butlers serving pot roast in the dining room. The blogs have a freshness and vitality; the newspapers are stony, like a statue.
Monday, October 01, 2007
Cleveland Plain Dealer Internal Memo: Connie Schultz Writes At 5th Grade Level
CLEVELAND (TDB) -- Newspaper editors are worried about how to grab readers. And a Cleveland Plain Dealer internal memo from last week urges reporters to keep things simple. Plain English and short, uncomplicated sentences are best. It notes that Sen. Sherrod Brown's spouse, columnist Connie Schultz, has written at a level appropriate for fifth graders. Meanwhile, Washington bureau reporter Sabrina Eaton seems to be rebuked. The memo says she wrote about Dennis Kucinich at a level appropriate for high school seniors, or subscribers to The New York Times. Her "reading ease" score was low.
Here's the complete text of the memo:
The Writer's Group has been discussing Jack Hart's book, A Writer's Coach. This week we talked about the chapter on clarity. Hart points out that we can test the readability of our stories with the Fesch-Kincaid test, which is available in all Word programs. To get the Fesch-Kincaid test, click on tools, then spelling and grammar, then click on options and check "show readability scores". The Flesch-Kincaid test expresses scores in grade levels, based on sentence lengths, word lengths and active voice.
"Most writers with Flesch-Kincaid scores of 10 or less can engage a large, diverse audience," Hart writes. He says Pulitzer Prize winner Tom Hallman usually averages about grade 7. "Clear direct writing produces the lowest scorers," Hart writes.
With that in mind, I tested some of our best work and compared it to the New York Times. I picked three New York Times page 1 stories from this week, all 2,000 words or more. They averaged 12th-grade level, from 20-24 words per sentence, more than 5 characters per word, and 18-20 percent passive sentences.
The computer also gives an ease of reading score. Readers Digest averages a 65 score, Time magazine about 52 and the Harvard Law Review low 30s. All of the New York Times stories scored below 45.
John Mangels' Plagued by Fear (Day 1) was an extremely complex story about plague research, science and academics. Yet it came in at a 10th grade level, with 17.8 words per sentence, 4.9 characters per word and only 4 percent passive voice. It's ease of reading score was 53.
Rachel Dissell's Johanna series (Day 1) scored at the 6th grade level. It also had only 6 percent passive sentences, 12.1 words per sentence (wps), 4.6 characters per word (cpw) and a reading ease score of 72.1.
Connie Schultz's Pulitzer finalist, Burden of Innocence, scored at the FIFTH-grade level. Burden had 4 percent passive sentences, 11.8 wps, 4.2 cpw and a reading ease score of 78, the highest of any I tested.
Andy's Last Secret, a national award winner from Joanna Connors, also scored at the 6th-grade level with only 1 percent passive sentences. Karen Long's Penny-Missouri winner, In Balraj's Realm, a complex story than (sic) delved into science, political, gender and ethnic issues, came in at grade level 7.7.
I also checked this year's New York Times' Pulitzer winner for feature writing and it scored much higher on the readability scale than the typical Times story. The first day of the series about an imam scored at the eighth-grade level with 13.7 wps and a 60 reading ease score.
Then I scored the three front-page stories from Monday's Plain
Dealer. The results:
Dennis Kucinich:
Grade level: 12.0.
Words per sentence: 22.
Characters per word: 4.9.
Passive sentences: 7 percent.
Reading ease: 39.
Tribe Time:
Grade level: 8.0.
Wps: 14.3 .
Cpw: 4.8 .
Passive: 7 percent.
Reading ease: 62.5.
Burke airport:
Grade level: 10.8.
Wps: 17.8.
Cpw: 5.1.
Passive: 4 percent.
Reading ease: 48.
The moral, I suppose, is that you don't have to write long sentences and use difficult words to write complicated stories. In fact, excellent writing is often concise writing. I also think it's worth noting that it's also more difficult to hone writing into that high ease of reading range. But it can be done with a little editing. My first draft of this memo came in at the 10th-grade level. I did a little editing and it is now at grade 7.1.
As a final note, years ago, when John Carroll was editor in Lexington, he refused to publish a series, Cheating Our Children, about the poor education in Kentucky until the writers got it down to grade level THREE. You can't write respectable journalism at the third-grade level, can you? The series was a Pulitzer finalist, won several major awards and, most importantly, led to a revolution in the Kentucky educational system.
I would be glad to show anyone how to use the Flesch test.
Here's the complete text of the memo:
The Writer's Group has been discussing Jack Hart's book, A Writer's Coach. This week we talked about the chapter on clarity. Hart points out that we can test the readability of our stories with the Fesch-Kincaid test, which is available in all Word programs. To get the Fesch-Kincaid test, click on tools, then spelling and grammar, then click on options and check "show readability scores". The Flesch-Kincaid test expresses scores in grade levels, based on sentence lengths, word lengths and active voice.
"Most writers with Flesch-Kincaid scores of 10 or less can engage a large, diverse audience," Hart writes. He says Pulitzer Prize winner Tom Hallman usually averages about grade 7. "Clear direct writing produces the lowest scorers," Hart writes.
With that in mind, I tested some of our best work and compared it to the New York Times. I picked three New York Times page 1 stories from this week, all 2,000 words or more. They averaged 12th-grade level, from 20-24 words per sentence, more than 5 characters per word, and 18-20 percent passive sentences.
The computer also gives an ease of reading score. Readers Digest averages a 65 score, Time magazine about 52 and the Harvard Law Review low 30s. All of the New York Times stories scored below 45.
John Mangels' Plagued by Fear (Day 1) was an extremely complex story about plague research, science and academics. Yet it came in at a 10th grade level, with 17.8 words per sentence, 4.9 characters per word and only 4 percent passive voice. It's ease of reading score was 53.
Rachel Dissell's Johanna series (Day 1) scored at the 6th grade level. It also had only 6 percent passive sentences, 12.1 words per sentence (wps), 4.6 characters per word (cpw) and a reading ease score of 72.1.
Connie Schultz's Pulitzer finalist, Burden of Innocence, scored at the FIFTH-grade level. Burden had 4 percent passive sentences, 11.8 wps, 4.2 cpw and a reading ease score of 78, the highest of any I tested.
Andy's Last Secret, a national award winner from Joanna Connors, also scored at the 6th-grade level with only 1 percent passive sentences. Karen Long's Penny-Missouri winner, In Balraj's Realm, a complex story than (sic) delved into science, political, gender and ethnic issues, came in at grade level 7.7.
I also checked this year's New York Times' Pulitzer winner for feature writing and it scored much higher on the readability scale than the typical Times story. The first day of the series about an imam scored at the eighth-grade level with 13.7 wps and a 60 reading ease score.
Then I scored the three front-page stories from Monday's Plain
Dealer. The results:
Dennis Kucinich:
Grade level: 12.0.
Words per sentence: 22.
Characters per word: 4.9.
Passive sentences: 7 percent.
Reading ease: 39.
Tribe Time:
Grade level: 8.0.
Wps: 14.3 .
Cpw: 4.8 .
Passive: 7 percent.
Reading ease: 62.5.
Burke airport:
Grade level: 10.8.
Wps: 17.8.
Cpw: 5.1.
Passive: 4 percent.
Reading ease: 48.
The moral, I suppose, is that you don't have to write long sentences and use difficult words to write complicated stories. In fact, excellent writing is often concise writing. I also think it's worth noting that it's also more difficult to hone writing into that high ease of reading range. But it can be done with a little editing. My first draft of this memo came in at the 10th-grade level. I did a little editing and it is now at grade 7.1.
As a final note, years ago, when John Carroll was editor in Lexington, he refused to publish a series, Cheating Our Children, about the poor education in Kentucky until the writers got it down to grade level THREE. You can't write respectable journalism at the third-grade level, can you? The series was a Pulitzer finalist, won several major awards and, most importantly, led to a revolution in the Kentucky educational system.
I would be glad to show anyone how to use the Flesch test.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)